Rob Sherman News

News about social injustice
and what I'm doing to stop it.

Serious Journalism, Professionally Written

Click on any picture for a larger image.

         October 15, 2010        

Moment of Silence decision REVERSED
by United States Court of Appeals

Share |

11:55 a.m.:  The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has issued its long-anticipated and easily predicted opinion, reversing by a vote of 2 to 1 the decision of the District Court in my daughter's case challenging the Illinois Student Prayer Act.

We knew, when we walked in the door of the Federal Courthouse on February 10th of this year, that we had no chance, based on the Reagan appointees that were assigned to hear the case.

One judge, Daniel Manion, was a graduate of the University of Notre Dame.  He made his mark in politics by sponsoring legislation as an Indiana State Senator to require that the Ten Commandments be posted in every public school classroom in Indiana.  We knew we had no chance with that guy.

The Opinion was written by Manion.  What does that say about the credibility of the decision?

Another judge, Ken Ripple, is a professor at the law school of the University of Notre Dame.   We all know how Notre Dame feels about the subject of prayer, so we knew that we had no chance with that guy, either.

The third judge was Ann Williams.  She graduated from the law school of --guess where? -- the University of Notre Dame and was appointed to the federal bench by -- guess who? -- Reagan, but she was appointed to the Appellate Court by Bill Clinton, so she dissented in the opinion.

So, what we're left is pure politics.  A clearly UNCONSTITUTIONAL  law has now been sustained by pure politics.  Both judges appointed by a Republican voted to sustain the UNCONSTITUTIONAL law, while both judges that were appointed by a Democrat (Williams to the Appellate Court and Gettleman appointed to the District court) easily recognized that the law is UNCONSTITUTIONAL.

The war continues to get this UNCONSTITUTIONAL law voided.

Previous Rob Sherman News stories about this subject matter:

Wednesday, March 24:  Appellate Court should legislate from the bench to reverse General Assembly on "Moment of Silence" law

Tuesday, March 23:  3 Reagan appointees with ties to Notre Dame hear "Moment of Silence" appeal

Monday, March 22:  General Assembly again rejects Sherman's efforts to amend "Moment of Silence" law

Tuesday, February 9:  Oral Arguments tomorrow at Appellate Court in Student Prayer Act "Moment of Silence" case

Wednesday, December 23:  "Moment of Silence" case update with copies of Appeals Briefs

Friday, October 9:  Moment of Silence Appeal Brief filed by Illinois Attorney General

Wednesday, September 30:  Americans are fleeing religion as atheism surges

Tuesday, September 15:  Dawn Sherman got God banned from homecoming

Tues., August 11:  David Black, Green Party candidate for Attorney General, rejects Moment of Silence defense

Tuesday, August 11:  Appellate Court rejects Madigan request to delay Moment of Silence case

Wed., August 5:  American Bar Association Journal features Shermans' successful challenge to "Moment of Silence" law

Tuesday, August 4:  Madigan stalls again, deceives court on Moment of Silence

Sunday, August 2:  Madigan decision in Moment of Silence case due tomorrow

Please tell your friends about Rob Sherman News through your social media networks and word of mouth.

E-mail comments about my stories to me at to let me know what you think.  Send personal comments, comments unrelated to this story or notification of typos that you see in any of my posts to the same e-mail address.

Thanks for visiting Rob Sherman News.

Your voluntary subscription to Rob Sherman News is appreciated to help offset the substantial cost of my work.  Thanks, in advance, for your participation in this manner.

Help support my work by purchasing a Rob Sherman News Mini-Crank Flashlight for $20.  It never needs batteries.  You just wind it up a few times and it works.  Remember, you're not paying twenty bucks just for a flashlight.  You are helping me to shine a light on and stop unconstitutional government policies and other catastrophically bad ideas by government and the private sector.

That's the value of what you are purchasing, and that's the difference between Rob Sherman Advocacy and most of the other groups.  They talk about the problems of state/church separation.  I do something about it and get the violations of your constitutional rights stopped.  Besides, there aren't that many of the Rob Sherman News Mini-Crank Flashlights, so you might be able to make a lot of money selling this rare collector's item in a few years.

Other views of the Rob Sherman News Mini-Crank Flashlight:    Close-up    Crank    Illuminated    Inch