Rob Sherman News
The hot social and political issues of the day

Serious Journalism, Professionally Written


 Share                                                  October 4, 2009                               

Recall and Term Limits war resumes
Monday (October 5, 2009) in Buffalo Grove

The ugly, destructive campaign to be able to screw your political enemies before your political enemies screw you, resumes at 7:30 p.m., Monday night (October 5, 2009), at the upcoming Buffalo Grove Village Board meeting (agenda).


The Buffalo Grove Village Board of Trustees, including the
Village President, along with the Village Manager and Village Clerk.
Photo from the Village of Buffalo Grove.

The Board of Trustees will consider adopting this Recall Ordinance, which would allow residents to seek to oust up to three elected officials at any regularly scheduled election.  Election law limits to three the number of referendum questions that can appear on the ballot at any one election.

Unfortunately, there are members of the Village Board who seek to use lawyer tricks to undo the results of the fair election that was held, earlier this year, at which time Lisa Stone was elected to be a Village Trustee.  The Recall Ordinance would allow the target of the ordinance, Trustee Stone, or any other elected officials, such as the main backers of the Recall Ordinance, to be ousted purely for political reasons, as no justification, such as misconduct, is required to place a recall referendum on the ballot.

I've asked Trustee Stone to respond to the recall scam by sponsoring a term limits ordinance.

I've always been opposed to term limits.  That' what we have elections, for, but if the election isn't going to mean anything, then we need term limits.

If "Recall for Political Reasons" becomes the law of the land in Buffalo Grove, elections won't mean anything.  If somebody who does not have the support of the majority of trustees gets elected to be a Trustee, the majority could simply conspire to get a Recall going and then appoint whoever they want to replace the ousted trustee.

After all, the top vote getter in the 2009 municipal election only got around 2,500 votes.  There are 25,000 registered voters in Buffalo Grove.  That means that only about 10% of the registered voters thought enough of the top vote getter to vote for him.  It also means that 90% of the registered voters did not like the top vote getter enough to bother to vote for him.

That means that just about anybody can be removed in a Recall, no matter how competent or well qualified that person is.

Under those terms, why would anybody even bother to run for election?  You're going to end up with a hand-picked, appointed trustee, anyway, so why bother running?

Why bother even voting?  Your vote won't matter one iota.

I urge the Village Board to reject this really bad idea, but my opinion probably won't matter at all.  They've surely made up their minds, that the majority has successfully manufactured a way to reverse the results of last April's election, and get away with it, so they surely are going to try to get away with it by adopting this Recall Ordinance.  I know how lawyers think.

However, several members of the community have informed me that they are standing by, waiting to file Notices of Recall against Trustee Jeffrey Berman, who is the sponsor the Recall Ordinance;  Trustee Steven Trilling, who seconded the Motion to Adopt the Ordinance, and Trustee Jeffrey Braiman, who is a chief backer of the Recall Ordinance.  These community members have assured me that they will get their Recall petitions against Berman, Trilling and Braiman signed and submitted before those three can get one against Trustee Stone signed and submitted.

Is that what we want in Buffalo Grove?  Do we really want to turn the focus of our community, away from the welfare of the community and, instead, on who can screw whom before the other person screws you?  I don't think that's what Money Magazine had in mind when it named Buffalo Grove as one of the 2009 winners in 100 Best Places to live in the United States.

The purpose for the Recall Ordinance, as stated in the proposed ordinance, is to ensure that "elected officials are responsible and accountable to the electorate for their behavior in office," and to ensure that "elected officials properly and appropriately discharge their responsibilities in office."  However, the lack of any requirement that an elected official violate any of those standards, or do anything else wrong, in order to be recalled, proves that those stated purposes are really merely a sham.  The real purpose for the Recall ordinance is political -- to reverse the results of a legitimate election, in which Trustee Stone (and two others) won and three others lost.

Don't do it!  Back off from this really bad idea.

Thanks to the power of the internet, THE WHOLE WORLD IS WATCHING.  If you are old enough to be one of the current members of the Buffalo Grove Village Board, you surely remember that phrase.  It comes from the 1968 Democratic Convention in Chicago, when the hippies (my kind of people) chanted that phrase to a worldwide television audience, while the police rioted at Grant Park and nearby in Downtown Chicago, in a bloody attempt to silence the hippies' political dissent regarding the Viet Nam War and the power of the Establishment.

I will be at the Buffalo Grove Village Board meeting on Monday, October 5, 2009, where I'll be offering my sentiments to the Board during Public Comment on the proposed Recall Ordinance.  I hope to see you there, too.

Please e-mail a comment to me at rob@robsherman.com to let me know what you think, and I'll post your comments, below.

I look forward to your comments on this one.  Let me know what you think about this attempt by lawyers to silence political dissent and to reverse the results of a lawful election.

Please tell your friends about this through your social media networks and word of mouth.

Send personal comments, comments unrelated to this story or notification of typos that you see in any of my posts to rob@robsherman.com.

Thanks for visiting Rob Sherman News.